ICML 2026 Reproduction Challenge • Independent Artifact Evidence Presentation
Findings: Released sampler AST (recpre/raven_modeling_minimal.py) confirms generate_diffusion_style applies inner_recurrence steps per outer iteration across active states, decodes logits, and appends new tokens. However, decoding occurs after the inner loop per outer step rather than after every individual inner step.
Findings: Source TeX audit reveals a citation mismatch: Theorem 4.2 is the prefilling result, while same-runtime decoding expressiveness is Theorem 4.4. No complete independently checkable proof of the decoding theorem is included in the v1 source.
| Outer Step | Active Positions Before | Recurrence Updates | Decoded Position | Candidate Positions | Retained Positions | Active Width / Bound |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Step 1 | [0] |
+4 updates | Position 0 | [1] |
[1] |
2 / 8 |
| Step 2 | [0, 1] |
+4 updates | Position 1 | [2] |
[2] |
3 / 8 |
| Step 3 | [0, 1, 2] |
+4 updates | Position 2 | [3] |
[3] |
4 / 8 |
| Step 4 | [0, 1, 2, 3] |
+4 updates | Position 3 | [4] |
[4] |
5 / 8 |
| Step 5 | [0, 1, 2, 3, 4] |
+4 updates | Position 4 | [5] |
[5] |
6 / 8 |
| Step 6 | [0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5] |
+4 updates | Position 5 | [6] |
[6] |
7 / 8 |
| Step 7 | [0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6] |
+4 updates | Position 6 | [7] |
[7] |
8 / 8 |
| Step 8 | [0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7] |
+4 updates | Position 7 | [8] |
[] |
8 / 8 |
Provenance Token:
arxiv:2510.14961v1+pdf-sha256:74e7985abe41ee2a75914a65e3778a15353fb0c0964d6ea34e7bfeb1f18312c8+source-sha256:60a795d123a2d2d642971834b6e0cba6dda80b5dfcd539f78d01639582d9c41d+github:seal-rg/recurrent-pretraining@1ea7220ec7eb42d13e89db0663df254d0bcdc28e+git-blob:recpre/raven_modeling_minimal.py@0e83a0766644df9113a8923f43350c6a1b5a182c
Input & Claim Hashes:
• Claim 1 SHA-256: d0da87ee16f7485d3dff369e7465f66299c55ac003a54e1cf8c00b3a0ad8b265
• Claim 2 SHA-256: 2e15221c8b5516b0ab705e29a3d7c5d924ed5f0187c970a0caf60a1402757804
• arxiv_submission.tex SHA-256: cdc058830d1e51f631e4fb8d1f2de0b79de91670fd4111646fe624f8c258d3b8
• raven_modeling_minimal.py SHA-256: 18fcacd53fb5696a76c0d3bda44480f2f3900aa9659c137a08962c593a9a9e42
• raven_modeling_minimal.py Git Blob: 0e83a0766644df9113a8923f43350c6a1b5a182c
• LICENSE (Apache-2.0) SHA-256: bc6c264d8ba4450599cf95c4699c6b82142f32ca1ecd91011c17b50a5a36a2f5
• ATTRIBUTION.md (CC-BY-4.0) SHA-256: 79775b50c72988b90eae75ef87e9d4df9dbd0bfceefaed60b398656a88d8a735